Montreal Mirror
Best of Montreal Readers' Poll

May 2010 Montreal Mirror 13 May 2010
        Best Local Actor
       1. Jay Baruchel
       2. William Shatner
       3. Marc-André Grondin
       4. Roy Dupuis
       5. Xavier Dolan
       6. Claude Legault
       7. Michel Côté
       8. Patrick Huard
       9. Brad Carmichael
      10. Rémy Girard
It’s a big week for Baruchel, the local kid made good in films like Knocked Up, who stars in fellow Montrealer Jacob Tierney’s The Trotsky, which hits theatres this Friday. Perennial fave Shatner maintains a strong position near the top of the list, double threat Dolan makes it onto both this one and the Best Director category, and good showings from Grondin ( C.R.A.Z.Y.), Legault ( Dans une galaxie près de chez nous), Côté (most recently in De père en flic), Huard ( Bon cop, bad cop), local theater mainstay Carmichael and local legend Girard ( Les Invasions barbares).

Also #7 in category -

Most Desirable Man
   
May 2009 Montreal Mirror 15 May 2009
         Best Local Actor
       1. Jay Baruchel
       2. Roy Dupuis
       3. Patrick Huard
       4. William Shatner
       5. Marc-André Grondin
       6. Brad Carmichael
       7. Dan Jeannotte
       8. Elias Toufexis
       9. Shawn Baichoo
      10. Adam Reid

Local boy made good Baruchel tops the list, above a few perennial faves like Dupuis, Huard, and of course the original Kirk himself. Up-and-comers include local theatre performer Carmichael, improv regular Jeannotte, Untimely Ripped’s Toufexis and Bionic Yahoo Baichoo. Self-promotion expert Adam Reid gets out his Facebook friends and squeaks in at #10.

Also #3 in category -

Most Desirable Man
   
May 2008 Montreal Mirror Archives 2008

 Best Actor
 1. Roy Dupuis
 2. William Shatner
 3. Jay Baruchel
 4. Patrick Huard
 5. Rémy Girard
 6. Kiefer Sutherland
 7. Derek Seguin
 8. Tristan D. Lalla
 9. Claude Legault
10. Adam Reid


No one can unseat perennial faves Dupuis and Shatner (who swap spots from last year) << not true! it was 2006 - viv >>, though local up-and-comer Jay Baruchel is hot on their heels Bon Cop, Bad Cop’s bad cop Huard is close behind, and comedian Derek Seguin joins the list for the first time.

 

Incidentally, Blasté came in #5 for Best Play.

Also #3 in category -

Most Desirable Man
   
May 2007 Montreal Mirror Archives 2007

 Best Actor
 1. 
Roy Dupuis
 2.  William Shatner
 3.  Patrick Huard
 4.  Donald Sutherland
 5.  Elias Toufexis
 6.  Tristan D. Lalla
 7.  Dan Jeannotte
 8.  Kiefer Sutherland
 9.  Marc-André Grondin
10. Michel Côté


No surprise that hometown studs Dupuis and Shatner take the top spots, with father-son duo the Sutherlands also showing strong. But those venerable names have some competition: up-and-comer Toufexis has made his mark with the Montreal-based Untimely Ripped theatre company and roles in shows like Stargate: Atlantis and Smallville, while stage vet Lalla can be seen in the upcoming film adaptation of The Secret. Also look out for improv-er Dan Jeannotte when his Uncalled For comedy troupe take the Fringe this year with two shows and The 13th Hour, a live late-night talk show.

Also #9 in category -

Most Desirable Man
   
May 2006 Montreal Mirror Archives 2006

 Best Local Actor
 1.  William Shatner
 2.  Roy Dupuis
 3.  Marc-André Grondin
 4.  Kiefer Sutherland
 5.  Michel Côté
 6.  Tristan D. Lalla
 7.  Derek Seguin
 8.  Donald Sutherland
 9.  Rémy Girard
10. Elias Toufexis

Wowing both audiences and critics alike with his recurring role in All-Bran ads, Captain Kirk proves that he’s better than ever (not to mention more regular). Which puts last year’s winner Roy Dupuis back in the runner-up position, a ranking the hunky actor is no stranger to (see 2002, 2003 and 2004.) Meanwhile, the rift between father and son widens with poor old Donald slipping two spots from last year as Kiefer’s 24 celebrity moves him up a spot. But the big news is C.R.A.Z.Y. star Marc-André Grondin making his debut on the top-10 while his co-star Michel Côté hangs tight, along with other BOM regs Rémy Girard (Les Boys IV) and Tristan D. Lalla (all-around popular guy and stage actor).
Also #7 in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 2005 Montreal Mirror Archives 2005
    Best Local Actor
    1.  Roy Dupuis
    2.  William Shatner
    3.  Elias Toufexis
    4.  Rémy Girard
    5.  Kiefer Sutherland
    6.  Donald Sutherland
    7.  David La Haye
    8.  Larry Day
    9.  Michel Côté
   10. Tristan D. Lalla
He's dead, Jim
>> Roy Dupuis finishes off William Shatner's reign as Best Local Actor

Roy Dupuis: the Susan Lucci of the Mirror's best-of awards or the victim of a ballot-stuffing campaign led by a splinter group of Trekkie terrorists? This is the question that has no-doubt been dogging the actor throughout his career. How could it not? Year after year, he took a backseat to William Shatner as Montreal's favourite actor. Well, those days are safely behind him now, because the people have spoken and the Mémoires affectives star is the new undisputed champ, an honour the modest actor predictably plays down.
"I'm just flattered being part of this group of nominees," says Dupuis. "And to tell you the truth, I haven't been paying much attention to the results. I mean, when you come in second, nobody calls you up to tell you, so you never hear about it."
Fair enough. But the question remains: who rocked the vote this year? Well, it wouldn't be a stretch to assume that a majority of the voters were the kind of women who get wet just thinking about Patrick Swayze in his high-waisted jeans. After all, as well as being a gifted actor, Dupuis is a walking cologne ad - what with his chiselled bone structure, deep husky voice and smoldering onscreen presence. According to Dupuis, however, his sex symbol status is pretty much wasted on him.
"It doesn't really change my life," says the 42-year-old man's man, who is calling from his work shed, where he's currently building a boat from scratch with his bare hands so he can sail around the world. "I just don't go out much anymore. But it was never something that I took advantage of... well, very much, anyway. I was always more interested in real relations. Maybe once in a while I indulged. But that was 10 years ago. I've been with the same woman for 10 years now."
His monogamous relationship with actress Céline Bonnier isn't the only area in his life where Dupuis is militantly loyal. For years now, Hollywood has been calling and Dupuis always gives the same answer: "Maybe if Montreal disappears and falls off the face of the planet. Seriously, something really drastic in my life
 
would have to happen for me to move down there. Home for me is here and it always will be."
As for helping Captain Kirk get through this difficult time, he's on his own as far as Dupuis is concerned.
"I don't have any advice for Mr. Shatner," he says. "He's been number one all these years, I think he can handle coming in second for a change."
Text by Sarah Rowland  
Also #5 in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 2004 Montreal Mirror Archives 2004
      Best Actor
     1.  William Shatner
     2.  Roy Dupuis
     3.  Rémy Girard
     4.  Kiefer Sutherland
     5.  Michel Côté
     6.  Omari Newton
     7.  Jay Baruchel
     8.  Elias Toufexis
     9.  Trent Pardy
    10. Donald Sutherland
As is clear (yet) again this year, Mirror readers have still not worked the Star Trek fromage thing out of their collective system. And Roy Dupuis, the ubiquitous vedette of screens big and small, is again at #2. Rémy Girard is a no-brainer, given his star turn in both The Barbarian Invasions and the massive hit TV sensation Les Bougon. Michel Côté gets spot #5 no doubt due to his performance as Patrick Huard's shrink in Sur le seuil. Meanwhile, theatre personalities Elias Toufexis and Trent Pardy are rapidly rising. While appearing in a production of Coriolanus at the Saidye last fall, Pardy drew comparisons to James Dean, Marlon Brando and Eminem.
Also honourable mention in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 2003 Montreal Mirror Archives 2003
     Best Actor
    1.  William Shatner
    2.  Roy Dupuis
    3.  Luc Picard
    4.  Shawn Baichoo
    5.  Andrew Farrar
    6.  Donald Sutherland
    7.  Kiefer Sutherland
    8.  Brian Warren
    9.  Matt Holland
   10. Jay Baruchel
Shatner, once again, wins easily. Many of the other actors have also skipped town, but they clearly have left an indelible mark on readers and upheld their thespian chic.
Also honourable mention in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 2002 Montreal Mirror Archives 2002
      Best Actor
     1.  William Shatner
     2.  Roy Dupuis
     3.  Lothaire Bluteau
     4.  Luc Picard
     5.  David LaHaye
Shatner’s incredible range and his ability to be taken seriously by audiences has apparently again overwhelmed our readership.
   
May 2001 Montreal Mirror Archives 2001
     Best Actor
    
No position
    1. Danny Smith
    2. William Shatner
    3. Matt Courtemanche
    4. Lothaire Bluteau
    5. Luc Picard
 
Honourable mention in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 2000 Montreal Mirror Archives 2000
     Best Actor
    1. William Shatner
    2. Luc Picard
    3. Lothaire Bluteau
    4. Bill Luxton
    5. Roy Dupuis
    6. Jacob Richmond
    7. Jacob Tierney
Scanning the results, something does appear to be clear: all of those theories about name recognition must be true. How else could someone as excruciating as Bill Shatner come ahead of someone as nuanced and brilliant as dear old Bluteau?
Also honourable mention in category - Best-dressed montrealer
   
May 1999 Montreal Mirror Archives 1999
Best Actor 
1.  Roy Dupuis
2.  Luc Picard
3= Nicholas Cage
3= William Shatner
4.  Alain Goulem
5.  Alexis Martin
Our dear, enlightened readers seem to be taking a while to catch on about this category. (And it's only been 10 years.) For future reference, this is meant to be a vote on local types. People from here! Mssrs. Pitt, Stallone, Willis, Travolta et al don't really qualify. (We'll let Nic Cage fly, as he did shoot the Brian De Palma film Snake Eyes here, but that movie really, really sucked.)
   
May 1998 Montreal Mirror Archives 1998
      Best Actor
     1. Roy Dupuis
     2. Luc Picard
     3. Michel Côté
     4. David La Haye
Local heartthrob Roy Dupuis, currently starring in the of-questionable-quality TV series Nikita (shot in Toronto), again tops our list as best male actor. Locals appear to be a bit confused about where some actors come from; some cited Mr. Bean and Jeff Bridges, neither of whom reside in our fair city. William Shatner, everyone's favourite starship captain--if not the world's greatest actor--garnered one vote.
Also honourable mention in category - Most Desirable Man
   
May 1997 Montreal Mirror Archives 1997
      Best Actor
     1. Roy Dupuis
     2. Sylvie Drapeau
    
3. Remy Girard (noted for his appearance
         on the Dunkin' Donuts ads)
Roy Dupuis tops our list again, and how he managed to survive that dud of a movie Screamers is beyond us, but apparently good looks can transcend really bad acting when it comes to star appeal.
Also #1 in category - Most Desirable Man
   
1990 - 1996 Online source not found
   

Return to Other Articles